"I've come to see that beauty is a thing that is without grace." - Jesca Hoop
To
someone who has been entranced by Ki-duk Kim from virtually the start, his
lauded victory in Venice was quite a long time coming. And for those waiting
with bated breath during his hiatus after 2008’s Dream (Bi-Mong) and the non-release of Arirang, Pieta is like pure oxygen – which is
ironic to say because it is also like having the wind knocked right out of you.
Kim’s latest is a triumph of emotional and existential depth, with a ghost of
the revenge genre that Korea has adapted into a national treasure. Does that slight
nod to convention and polish make Pieta
commercial? Hardly. Pieta - like Michael
Haneke’s Funny Games - is as grizzly
in its implications, mood, texture, and psychology of violence as a grindhouse film is in
splatter effects. As any studied artist knows, the imagination is limitless
where an image is limited, just as Kim knows that silence is limitless where words are limited. Pieta
balances the shock of the image with the task of imagining throughout, not only
with violence, but with emotional motivations and the variation between visual
and spoken language.
In
small ways Pieta marks a shift in
Kim’s cinema. Not a distinct leap, but certainly a lateral advance. For one
thing, the mostly handheld cinematography is a bit looser, and the editing is on
the whole a bit faster. There is also a newfound sense of darkness and shadow
that feels like a continuation of his nocturnal exercises in Dream taken to more noir-like, if not
painterly heights. Kim’s lighting – or rather his darkening - enhances Pieta’s foul and grey environs. In all
the important ways though - the ways deeply rooted to his identity as a visual
storyteller fascinated by the physicality and brutality of human emotion - Kim
remains the same uncompromising artist invested in the marginalized. Pieta is both a return to form and refinement of form.
Kang-do
(Lee Jung-jin in a visceral embodied pefromance) is a singular and singularly
unsympathetic man, without family or scruples and a limited vocabulary. He
works as an enforcer for a loan shark. His
employer has a staggering policy which demands 10x return on all loans. Poor
machinists and small-scale industrial workers take out loans to stay afloat in utter
desperation, but incur the wrath of Kang-do when they are unable to pay. To
recover the astronomical interests, the debtors would sign an insurance claim
in the case of a handicapping, which gives Kang-do his weapon. He cripples the
debtors so that they can file the claim and use that money to pay off their
debt, a truly vicious but effective system.
Kang-do lives a primal existence, and is
likewise animalistic in his behavior. There is a touch of “a boy raised by
wolves” in his demeanor, and his unblinking savagery. Even the way he eats has
a primitive aspect – gutting a chicken on his bathroom floor and boiling the
whole bird in a pot. Kang-do lives in an impoverished industrial section of the
city, which is soon to be overtaken by skyscrapers as the city center expands.
In this Kim creates a vague subtext of socio-economic disparity. Alleyways are
littered with metal junk and scrap, dingy concrete, and greyness. Kim depicts
something highly specific and tactile in the world of Pieta that at times feels like a black and white film in color.
One day Kang-do is visited by a strange woman (Jo
Min-su) who claims to be his mother begging for forgiveness for abandoning him
at birth. The visitation of his this woman stirs up emotions in Kang-do that
had been fueling his cruelty all along, but now he is forced to confront them
and process new ideas about his identity as a man apart, without origin or
morality. He rejects her first attempts at reconciliation, but her persistence
pays off by degrees. Jo Min-su is affecting and unforgettable. Like a soul
stripped bare, her fragility and her strength are simultaneous, as is her
mystery. Her injection into Kang-do’s life however goes both ways, and she
finds herself confronting her own shadowed past.
That all sounds fine and good, but in a Kim
film, nothing happens easily and nothing unfolds with particular grace. In
fact, Kim’s cinema is that of the gracelessness that is humanity. With newfound
love comes the fear of loss, the very insecurity of possession. In short, all
things contain their opposite, and hold within the seed of their negation. How
long can a second chance at childhood last?
Pieta has much in common with his 2006 film Samaritan Girl with its religious
references (not that they reference the same religion), its sense of irony tied
to those symbolisms, and in the depiction of a strained bond between a child
and their only parent, albeit inverse in the gender and in the flow of aggression. Even the vengeful father figure in Samaritan Girl,
mutated by his misapprehension of his daughter’s secretive illicit
actions has a flavor of Kang-do’s pure pitiless spirit. Pieta also recalls Kim’s earlier works, like Address Unknown and Bad Guy,
which are remarkably unsympathetic and focus on the lower classes, the
impoverished, criminals, prostitutes, etc. The one thing Kim never loses sight
of, no matter the social strata, is the human…. the aching, screaming, brutal, silent, desperate, passionate,
inconsistent human ever competing against the circumstance of existence.* A version of this article is published in the Spring 2013 Korean Quarterly *
